Hulu Legal Drama Draws One-Star Reviews Amid High Viewership

The second season of the Hulu legal drama All's Fair premiered on November 4 on Hulu and Disney+, immediately facing a wave of one-star reviews from major outlets. Critics have questioned whether the series has improved since its debut in November 2025, with some labeling it a potential candidate for the worst television show of the 21st century.

The series is created by Ryan Murphy and features a high-profile cast including Kim Kardashian, Naomi Watts, Niecy Nash, Sarah Paulson, Teyana Taylor, and Glenn Close. Despite this ensemble talent, early reactions to the new episodes mirror the complaints raised during the show's initial run. Reviewers remain divided on the production's intent, struggling to determine if it is aiming for serious legal drama or self-aware comedy.

Ed Power, writing for The Telegraph, gave the season one star. He expressed sympathy for Watts and Close, comparing their involvement to Watts' role in David Lynch's Mulholland Drive. Power suggested that the project did not match the abilities of the two accomplished actresses and questioned why they were attached to such a production.

Lucy Mangan of The Guardian also assigned a one-star rating. However, she noted a shift in the show's appeal, admitting that the series was becoming more entertaining. Mangan suggested the program was moving toward a specific type of television that is enjoyable precisely because it is poorly executed.

Jonathon Wilson from Ready Steady Cut offered a two-star review. Wilson stated that he struggled to understand the show's direction, noting that it often seemed caught between two different approaches. He observed that a campy satire starring Kardashian could work, but the current execution failed to commit to that style.

Kim Kardashian defended the show's performance, citing the strong viewership numbers. She explained that the harsh reviews attracted an audience driven by curiosity. "I just thought it was so funny that people came in and wanted to hate on it so much that the hate turned into viewers wanting to see how bad it was," Kardashian said. She noted that this dynamic helped the show remain one of the most-watched programs for weeks.

Kardashian previously admitted that the critical reception made her worry about the series' impact on her career. However, she pointed out that the criticism served as a marketing tool, drawing in viewers who wanted to see for themselves. The show's ability to convert negative publicity into ratings has kept it in the conversation despite the poor critical consensus.

The new season is now streaming on Hulu and Disney+. Early data indicates that the audience engagement remains strong even as the critical scores stay low. The next phase of the season's performance will depend on whether the show can maintain its viewership momentum through the upcoming episodes.